The holidays are supposed to be magical. So why do so many moms end up exhausted, overwhelmed, and counting down the days until they're over?
For many women, the answer has a lot to do with the invisible holiday mental load: the planning, organizing, anticipating, and emotional responsibility involved in making the season special for everyone else.
Maybe you're already thinking about coordinating family gatherings, buying gifts, planning holiday activities, scheduling pictures, organizing matching pajamas, and figuring out how to make everything feel special for your children. You're also trying to maintain traditions, manage extended family expectations, and somehow keep up with all the responsibilities of everyday life.
And while everyone else is looking forward to the holidays, you may find yourself wondering how you're going to make it all happen.
Last night, I co-hosted Boundaries, Babe., a virtual conversation for moms about navigating holiday expectations, family guilt, people-pleasing, and the challenges of setting boundaries. These are topics that come up frequently in my work as a perinatal psychologist, and they're especially relevant as we head into the holiday season.
As I've been thinking about the relationship between boundaries and the holiday mental load, I keep coming back to a bigger question: Why do so many moms feel personally responsible for everyone else's holiday experience?
Because while the sheer amount of work involved in making the holidays happen can be overwhelming, I think there's something deeper going on. For many women, creating meaningful holiday experiences has become another responsibility tied to their identity as a mother.
We don't just want our families to enjoy the holidays. We can begin to feel as though it's our job to make sure they do.
The Invisible Holiday Mental Load That Moms Carry
When we talk about the mental load of motherhood, we're referring to more than the physical tasks required to care for a family. We're also talking about the ongoing cognitive work of anticipating needs, planning ahead, remembering details, making decisions, and ensuring that everything gets done.
The holidays introduce an entirely new category of responsibilities into that already demanding system.
It's not just buying gifts. It's remembering who needs a gift, deciding what to buy, keeping track of what you've purchased, coordinating with relatives, wrapping everything, and making sure nothing is forgotten.
It's not just hosting a holiday gathering. It's thinking about the menu, dietary restrictions, timing, childcare, nap schedules, seating arrangements, and whether everyone will feel included.
And it's not just creating memories for your children. It's researching activities, making reservations, buying supplies, planning outfits, taking pictures, and remembering to document the moments you're working so hard to create.
Much of this work is invisible, particularly when everything goes according to plan. The gifts appear, the traditions happen, and the family enjoys the experience without necessarily recognizing the amount of planning that made it possible.
Sociologist Allison Daminger's 2019 research on cognitive household labor identified four components of this invisible work: anticipating needs, identifying options, making decisions, and monitoring progress. Her findings highlighted how women often carry a disproportionate share of this responsibility, particularly the less visible work of anticipating and monitoring household needs.
A study by Elizabeth Aviv, Darby Saxbe, and colleagues, published in Archives of Women's Mental Health in 2025, examined cognitive household labor among 322 mothers of young children. The researchers found that mothers reported carrying a disproportionate share of this work and that greater cognitive responsibility was associated with increased stress, burnout, depressive symptoms, and poorer relationship functioning.
Although these studies examined household labor more broadly rather than holiday-specific responsibilities, they help explain why adding another layer of planning and emotional responsibility can feel particularly overwhelming for moms.
For many women, the result is a familiar feeling: everyone else gets to experience the holiday, while they're responsible for making it happen.
Why Do Moms Feel Responsible for Everyone Else's Holiday Experience?
I think the pressure to create holiday magic is connected to broader expectations about motherhood and the roles women often play within families.
From a young age, many women receive messages about being thoughtful, nurturing, organized, and attentive to other people's needs. These qualities can be meaningful strengths, and they can also create an expectation that we're responsible for anticipating what everyone needs before they even ask.
Motherhood can intensify that sense of responsibility.
We want our children to have wonderful experiences. We want them to feel loved, connected, and excited about family traditions. And because these experiences matter to us, it's understandable that we invest time and energy into creating them.
The challenge arises when we begin to believe that the quality of our children's holiday experience is a reflection of our competence as mothers.
Suddenly, forgetting a tradition, skipping an activity, or deciding not to host can feel like more than a practical choice. It can feel like we're failing to give our children something important.
Social media can make these expectations even harder to navigate. We're exposed to carefully curated images of elaborate decorations, themed activities, perfectly coordinated family pictures, and traditions that seem effortless from the outside.
Even when we know intellectually that these images don't represent the full picture, they can influence what we believe we should be doing.
And before we know it, we're comparing the reality of our family's holiday season to an idealized version of someone else's.
How Perfectionism Turns Holiday Traditions Into Pressure
For moms who struggle with perfectionism, the holidays can become an especially challenging time.
Perfectionism isn't simply about wanting things to look nice or enjoying a well-organized celebration. It often involves holding ourselves to exceptionally high standards and attaching significant meaning to whether we meet them.
In motherhood, those standards can extend to the experiences we believe we're supposed to create for our children.
Maybe you feel pressure to make every holiday memorable because you worry that childhood is passing too quickly. Perhaps you want to recreate the traditions you loved growing up, or compensate for experiences you wish you'd had. You might also feel pressure to make your child's first few holidays particularly special, even when they're too young to understand much of what's happening.
None of these motivations are inherently problematic. Traditions can create a sense of connection, belonging, and continuity within families.
The difficulty comes when the desire to create meaningful experiences becomes an obligation to make every experience exceptional.
We can become so focused on how things are supposed to look or feel that we struggle to enjoy what's actually happening.
And when something inevitably doesn't go according to plan, whether it's a sick child, a missed nap, a family disagreement, or an activity that doesn't live up to expectations, we may experience disproportionate frustration or disappointment.
I think it's worth considering how often the pressure to create a perfect holiday prevents us from being present for the holiday we're actually having.
Why Holiday Expectations and People-Pleasing Are So Closely Connected
One of the central themes of Boundaries, Babe. was the difficulty of navigating other people's expectations while trying to make decisions that feel right for ourselves and our families.
We talked a lot about the difference between setting boundaries and holding them. It takes practice and understanding how to tolerate the discomfort of your own and other’s feeling when a boundary is set. This is probably the hardest part. We talked about strategizing this holiday season to team up with another family member, practice self care, and plan to talk about boundaries ahead of time.
We also recognized that the holidays can be a heightened emotional time, and that there is some room for grace around everyone’s feelings and reactions. It’s best to communicate openly about wants and needs upfront, rather than spew hurt once we’ve reached a boiling point.
I am grateful for the individuals who attended Boundaries, Babe and gave themselves the extra boost they needed for this holiday season.
The holidays can bring competing expectations into particularly sharp focus.
You may feel responsible for maintaining traditions that have existed for years, coordinating visits between families, purchasing gifts for extended relatives, or making sure everyone has enough time with your children.
And after becoming a parent, some of those longstanding expectations may no longer work for your family.
Maybe traveling to multiple gatherings with a baby or toddler feels overwhelming. Perhaps you want to establish your own traditions at home, or you're realizing that the number of commitments you've agreed to leaves very little time for your immediate family to enjoy the season.
For women who have spent years being accommodating or maintaining family relationships, changing those patterns can feel uncomfortable.
You may know that a particular commitment isn't realistic and still find yourself saying yes because you're worried about disappointing someone.
This is where I think the connection between people-pleasing and the holiday mental load becomes particularly important. Sometimes we're not only taking responsibility for organizing the holiday experience. We're also taking responsibility for how everyone feels about it.
And that's an enormous amount of responsibility for one person to carry.
One of the ideas I hope moms take away from conversations about boundaries is that we can care about other people's feelings and still make decisions they don't agree with.
We can appreciate the traditions we grew up with and allow them to evolve. We can value extended family relationships and still prioritize the needs of the family we're building.
How the Holiday Mental Load Creates Resentment Between Partners
One of the more complicated consequences of carrying the holiday mental load is the resentment that can develop between partners.
You may genuinely enjoy planning traditions and creating special experiences for your family. At the same time, you might feel frustrated that you're the person who has to remember, organize, and execute everything.
Sometimes this frustration becomes especially noticeable when a partner asks, "What can I do to help?"
While the offer may be well-intentioned, it can reinforce the idea that one person is responsible for managing the holiday experience and the other is available to assist.
There's a meaningful difference between helping with a task and sharing responsibility for making sure that task happens.
For example, asking your partner to wrap the gifts may take something off your to-do list. Having your partner take responsibility for selecting, purchasing, and wrapping gifts for certain family members removes the responsibility of managing that entire process.
That distinction matters because delegating tasks still requires someone to identify what needs to happen, communicate expectations, and monitor whether the work gets done.
When one parent consistently carries that responsibility, resentment can develop even when the other partner is contributing in visible ways.
And resentment can become particularly confusing during the holidays because we're supposed to be enjoying ourselves.
You might feel guilty for being frustrated with your partner, irritated by the demands of the season, or disappointed that an experience you worked so hard to create doesn't feel particularly enjoyable.
Rather than dismissing those feelings, I think they're worth examining. Sometimes resentment is an indication that our responsibilities, expectations, or needs aren't being adequately acknowledged.
How to Reduce the Holiday Mental Load Without Giving Up the Traditions You Love
I don't think the solution to holiday overwhelm is simply telling moms to do less. While that advice may be well-intentioned, it overlooks the emotional and relational dynamics that make doing less so difficult in the first place.
For many women, reducing the holiday mental load requires changing how they think about responsibility, success, and what makes the season meaningful.
Before automatically committing to another year of traditions and obligations, consider which experiences genuinely matter to you.
Are there activities your family looks forward to every year? Traditions that create a sense of connection? Experiences that feel meaningful rather than obligatory?
It's worth distinguishing between the things you want to do and the things you've come to believe you should do.
You may discover that some traditions are worth the effort, while others no longer reflect your family's needs or priorities.
And you can let some things go without replacing them with something equally elaborate.
Share Ownership, Not Just Tasks
If you're parenting with a partner, consider having a conversation about the responsibilities involved in the holiday season before the planning is already underway.
Rather than creating a list of tasks for your partner to complete, discuss which areas each of you can take responsibility for from beginning to end.
This might mean one person managing gifts for extended family while the other organizes travel arrangements, or dividing responsibility for holiday meals, activities, and childcare logistics.
The goal isn't necessarily to split every task equally. It's to create a more intentional and sustainable distribution of responsibility so that one person isn't carrying the entire mental load.
Set Boundaries Around Holiday Expectations
Sometimes reducing the holiday mental load means becoming more comfortable saying no.
That might involve declining an invitation, limiting how many gatherings you attend, simplifying gift exchanges, or communicating that your family will be celebrating differently this year.
For moms who struggle with people-pleasing, this can be especially challenging because the discomfort of disappointing someone may feel more difficult than simply agreeing to another obligation.
And while compromise can be important, it's also worth recognizing that you can care about someone else's feelings and still make a decision that works for your family.
A boundary doesn't have to be universally popular to be appropriate.
Let Your Children Experience a Good Enough Holiday
This may be one of the most important shifts for moms who feel pressure to make everything magical.
Our children don't need every holiday moment to be extraordinary. They can enjoy traditions that are simple, imperfect, or different from what we originally imagined.
And sometimes the experiences we put the most pressure on ourselves to create aren't the ones our children enjoy most.
A toddler may be more interested in the wrapping paper than the gift. A carefully planned outing may end with someone crying because they're tired. A holiday meal may look nothing like the picture you had in your head.
Those moments can be disappointing, and they don't necessarily mean the experience was unsuccessful.
We can give ourselves permission to create meaningful traditions without expecting every moment to feel magical.
Make Sure There's Room for You to Enjoy the Holidays, Too
When we're focused on creating experiences for everyone else, it's easy to forget that we're supposed to be participating in them.
Consider what would make the season enjoyable for you. Maybe it's having a quiet morning at home, spending time with friends, attending a favorite tradition, or simply having fewer obligations.
Your preferences don't have to come last because you're the parent.
Making room for your own enjoyment doesn't take anything away from your children. It allows you to participate in the experiences you're creating rather than feeling solely responsible for managing them.
A Reflection on Boundaries, Motherhood, and Holiday Magic
As I reflect on Boundaries, Babe., I keep coming back to how closely boundaries are connected to the expectations we place on ourselves.
Sometimes the pressure we experience comes from other people. Family members have preferences, traditions carry emotional significance, and relationships can become complicated when we make different choices.
And sometimes the pressure comes from within. We hold ourselves to standards that nobody explicitly asked us to meet, assume responsibility for things that could be shared, and feel guilty when we consider doing less.
Learning to set boundaries involves recognizing both.
We can communicate limits with the people around us, and we can also reconsider the expectations we've created for ourselves.
For moms, I think that second part can be especially difficult because so much of our identity becomes intertwined with caring for other people.
We want our children to have meaningful experiences, and we want to be present enough to enjoy those experiences with them.
The goal isn't to stop caring about traditions or making an effort. It's to recognize when our desire to create something special has become another source of pressure, perfectionism, and resentment.
Perhaps the most important reminder as we enter the holiday season is that making memories with our families doesn't require us to be responsible for every detail.
A good enough holiday is still a good holiday. And moms deserve to enjoy it, too. And as we said last night, “wishing you a peaceful, joyful, and boundaried holiday!”
Therapy for Moms Navigating Perfectionism, Anxiety, and the Mental Load
I'm Dr. Vanessa Vitiello, a licensed psychologist specializing in perinatal mental health, anxiety, perfectionism, and the emotional transitions of motherhood.
Through Vitiello Psychological Services of New Jersey, I help women navigate the pressure to do it all, the invisible responsibilities of parenting, and the challenges of setting boundaries while maintaining meaningful relationships.
Therapy can provide a space to better understand the patterns contributing to overwhelm, develop greater confidence in your decisions, and find ways to approach motherhood that feel more aligned with your values.
I offer virtual therapy in New Jersey, New York, and PSYPACT states.
Visit my about me page to learn more about my practice or schedule your complimentary consultation here.
Research References
Daminger, A. (2019). The cognitive dimension of household labor. American Sociological Review, 84(4), 609–633.
Aviv, E., Waizman, Y., Kim, E., Liu, J., Rodsky, E., & Saxbe, D. (2025). Cognitive household labor: Gender disparities and consequences for maternal mental health and wellbeing. Archives of Women's Mental Health, 28, 5–14.